YouTube – Copyright Disputes

A few days ago I mentioned on Google+ that the clean up of my YouTube channel had begun, the reason being is that my account had been dragged in to disrepute. Firstly, I’d like to hold my hand up and admit that in the past I have used songs that maybe I shouldn’t have. I earned myself a copyright dispute on a few of them but they were quickly resolved and an Advert was placed on my video, this however didn’t cause any problems…. Videos like my recording of Mark Knopfler from the LG Arena when I was stood at the edge of the stage, you know… the one where I shook the legend’s hand after he had played “So Far Away”, not that I like to go on about it 🙂

20131212-105812.jpg

Anyway, back to my original point. Over the last year or so I have been getting back in to YouTube again, my videos have been getting longer and the amount of time I have dedicated to video has become much greater… So it is with great regret that I have had to make the call to delete a few videos that have earned me copyright disputes. Surprisingly it isn’t the videos that have been online for years like the ones I uploaded back in 2007 before the giant that is Google swallowed YouTube. The videos that have caused the issues and dragged my account in to disrepute are the ones where I have used Royalty Free or Creative Commons audio.

I have honestly lost count of how many times I have earned a dispute for using Royalty Free sounds and Audio, despite the fact I always comply 100% with the terms of the license. For instance, my latest video at this moment in time is my walk along the Great Ridge in the Peak District. In this video I used a Creative Commons Licensed song by an Artist called Dexter Britain which I found on the FMA Website. Dexter states that you may use the audio in any way you choose providing you give a link back to the original audio and a credit to him. As I mentioned a moment ago, I complied 100% with the license and included the required credits and links in the description of the video… Over the last 3-4 weeks I have been hit with a total of 6 copyright Disputes, All of which basically had the same information and to which I replied with the same response… “I have a license under the creative commons to use the audio and I have included the relevant links and credits as stated in the agreement of use” etc etc

20131212-105826.jpg

This is not the only time I have been given multiple disputes for the same audio, my latest claim against the “Forest Sound” which I used in my #MicroAdventure video is by “Baby Sleep CD”. Apparently I have used audio from them but in reality it was a Royalty Free Sound from the library included with Apple Final Cut Pro. As you can imagine I have had to keep reiterating the fact when replying to the disputes.

I really have lost count of the times I have been hit with claims in the last year or so, the most disheartening fact is that it is against sounds that have been used legitimately. It really pained me to have to delete old videos that I had created years ago in order to lift myself out of Bad Standing because of the sheer amount of disputes I am waiting for them to resolve. I am currently waiting on more than 10 dispute replies for the Royalty free sounds. The worst thing about this is that it is totally out of my hands and all I can really do is wait for the claim to “time out”. In the meantime my account was downgraded so I was unable to upload videos longer than 15 minutes. No big deal I hear you shout, I was just concerned that the end result would be a termination of my YouTube account and the loss of all my videos from 2007 to the present day.

20131212-105853.jpg

Get to the point Dean… ok, so my main issue is that the copyright disputes are being triggered mostly by an automated system. YouTube scans every video now days for any form of copyright infringement, very efficiently too it seems for the majority of the time. The most annoying part about this is that in the times that it gets it wrong I risk my account being limited or closed. Basically I’m just sounding off because I’m seriously disheartened with YouTube at the moment, I do understand they need to protect people’s creative work and I fully support that. The annoying part is that when I do my very best to be good and use Royalty Free audio I still get stung by a mindless system where it seems to take an age to resolve inaccurate claims. Let’s face it though… I’m just annoyed because I’ve had to delete a video I made in 2010 that had more than 150,000 views and I was proud of it 🙂

UPDATE – 24th December 2013

Well, Thankfully I can now say that normal service has been resumed. Over the last few days a handful of the remaining false claims have timed out which has put me back in good standing… All is well. Another good thing is that on the day everything was returned to normal I was sent a £60 payment by Google for the adverts I have on my content 🙂

Screen Shot 2013-12-24 at 00.55.25

16 thoughts on “YouTube – Copyright Disputes

  1. Vimeo does look very good and I follow some great users on there. I don’t know or understand what the problem with Google+ is (but my son is complaining about that) — however getting into a copyright dispute on legally used music and that affecting your whole account is pretty ropey – I imagine the system is completely automatic and noone with any common sense will look into it

    Like

    1. The Google+ part of it isn’t as bad for me as it is for a few of my mates, I have been using Google+ for a long while anyway so it’s not such a shock.. Like you say though if you have too many copyright disputes open at any one time you risk having your account closed. They are scanning every new video as it goes up but are also gradually scanning all old videos too. That has been my issue, I have a few recent royalty free issues but then they will find another from years ago which tipped it over the allowed limit I think 🙂 Hope your doing well Paul, thanks for reading and commenting

      Like

  2. Part of the problem is how you compose the video. Sometimes I use music in my videos, and they are always royalty-free pieces use legitimately. But in the majority of my videos I use ambient sound, recorded on site. I know that adding music might ‘add interest’ but I am interested in audio authenticity. I want my videos to have the authentic sounds of the places where they were shot. I have 640 videos now uploaded, and very few copyright disputes.

    Like

    1. I understand what your saying Richard, my next purchase is a Zoom H2N microphone which I can use with my Canon DSLR to capture better audio. The problem I have is wind noise when out in the hills and have struggled to combat it with the inbuilt microphone on the Canon & my GoPro.

      Like

    1. It does seem that way at the minute, there seems to have been a big backlash in the last few months after the commenting change and how they are forcing people on to Google+. The copyright issues have been so frustrating for me. You try and be good and only use royalty free audio, only to continuously get stung regardless. ‘F’ Them 🙂

      Like

    2. It does seem that way at the minute, there seems to have been a big backlash in the last few months after the commenting change and how they are forcing people on to Google+. The copyright issues have been so frustrating for me. You try and be good and only use royalty free audio, only to continuously get stung regardless. ‘F’ Them 🙂

      Like

      1. Totally agree. The Google + thing shouldn’t have been forced upon people. Now the copyright issues are the icing on the cake.

        I also follow some PC game review sites and they have been hit extremely hard and it could ruin peoples livelihood.

        It is a damn shame you had to remove some of your great video’s, even more so if you had monetized some of them. If for example you had a 2 hour video with a 10 second piece of someone’s music on it then the copyright holder can claim the full 100% revenue from it, it’s so wrong. Already some people are jumping ship to Vimeo. Let’s hope Youtube fix this.
        Keep the videos coming pal 🙂

        Like

      2. Thats a good point Chris, I have a few really long videos that may only have a few seconds of audio used. It’s a shame really as I had got back in to YouTube over this last year and now my passion has faded a little for it. I think I just need to get back out walking again asap 🙂 thanks for commenting mate

        Like

    1. Thanks, there has been a number of things recently that have made me loose faith in the online world. However, Nice comments on videos and blog posts always restore my faith 🙂

      Like

    2. Thanks, there has been a number of things recently that have made me loose faith in the online world. However, Nice comments on videos and blog posts always restore my faith 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s